Issue 1: Rewrite the Narrative - The Gap
- Katie Katz
- Mar 15
- 4 min read
The Civil-Military Divide
The divide between the military community and the general public is an issue that has long persisted, growing more pronounced over the years. A 2012 Pew Research study revealed that 84% of post-9/11 veterans and 71% of the general public agree that most Americans do not understand military life. This is not a new phenomenon, but it has far-reaching consequences that affect policy-making, veteran reintegration, public support for military initiatives, and overall national unity.
In this blog post, we will break down the roots of this divide, its impacts on service members and civilians alike, and how we can bridge this gap by rewriting the narrative surrounding veterans and military life.
Understanding the Divide: Why Does It Exist?
1. The All-Volunteer Force and the Disconnection from Civilian Life
Since the end of the draft in 1973, the U.S. military has been an all-volunteer force (AVF). This shift created a professionalized military class, leading to a disconnect between those who serve and the civilian population. Only about 7% of U.S. adults are military veterans, and less than 1% actively serve in the armed forces today. This stark contrast means fewer families have direct ties to the military, leading to a lack of firsthand knowledge or understanding of military life.
2. Media Portrayals and Public Perception
Media narratives about the military often fall into two extremes:
The Hero Narrative: Veterans are portrayed as larger-than-life heroes, glorified in films, news, and speeches.
The Broken Veteran Narrative: Veterans are depicted as struggling individuals with PTSD, homelessness, or addiction.
Both of these stereotypes fail to capture the complex realities of military service and post-service life. Many veterans feel that these portrayals simplify their experiences and make it harder for them to integrate into civilian society.
3. Policy-Making Without Veteran Input
Decisions about military funding, veteran healthcare, and foreign policy are often made by politicians with limited military experience. This can result in policies that don’t fully address the needs of service members or accurately reflect the realities of military service.
4. Cultural and Social Barriers
Veterans often report feeling isolated from their civilian peers, who may not understand their experiences or struggles. Differences in values, discipline, communication styles, and workplace expectations can make it difficult for veterans to transition into civilian jobs or social circles.
The Real-World Impacts of This Gap
1. Challenges in Veteran Reintegration
When the public does not understand military service, it can make the transition to civilian life harder for veterans. Misconceptions about military experiences can lead to difficulties in employment, social interactions, and even mental health support. Employers may hesitate to hire veterans due to concerns about PTSD, while civilians may struggle to relate to veterans’ experiences, leading to isolation.
2. Reduced Public and Political Support for Veterans
A lack of understanding can result in inadequate public and political support for veterans' issues. Many civilians assume that the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) provides comprehensive care, when in reality, many veterans face challenges accessing healthcare, education benefits, and job training programs.
3. Ineffective Advocacy for Military Families
The families of service members also suffer due to this gap. Spouses and children of deployed military personnel experience unique challenges that are often overlooked in public discourse. Military families move frequently, deal with long deployments, and often struggle with financial stability—all issues that deserve greater awareness and support.
How to Rewrite the Narrative
1. Education and Awareness Initiatives
One of the most effective ways to bridge the gap is through education. Schools and community organizations should integrate military history and the realities of service into their curricula. Programs that bring veterans into classrooms to share their experiences can foster understanding and appreciation.
2. More Accurate Media Representation
Hollywood, news outlets, and social media platforms must do better in portraying military life accurately. Rather than glorifying or victimizing veterans, media should highlight diverse experiences, including:
The transition process from active duty to civilian life
The range of jobs and skills developed in the military
The strong community and leadership development aspects of military service
3. Policy Changes to Improve Veteran Support
The government can take concrete steps to close this gap by:
Including more veterans in policymaking roles
Expanding transition assistance programs for service members leaving the military
Improving mental health and employment support services
4. Encouraging Civil-Military Engagement
Programs that connect civilians with veterans, such as mentorship programs, volunteer opportunities, and public speaking events, can help bridge the divide. Encouraging businesses to hire veterans and educating employers on the value of military experience can also facilitate smoother transitions.
5. Shifting the Conversation Around PTSD and Veteran Mental Health
PTSD is often misunderstood by the general public. While it is a serious condition, it is not a universal experience for all veterans. Raising awareness about the diversity of mental health experiences within the military community can help reduce stigma and promote better support systems.
A Call to Action
The gap between the military and civilian populations is not inevitable. By making conscious efforts to understand, connect with, and support veterans and their families, we can rewrite the narrative.
This isn’t just a military issue—it’s a societal one. Bridging this divide is essential for national unity, policy effectiveness, and the well-being of those who have served.
Now is the time to take action. Whether through education, media advocacy, policy change, or direct community engagement, we all have a role to play in ensuring that veterans are not only respected but also truly understood.
Let’s rewrite the narrative—together.
Comments